The Guardian view on cheap train travel: a lesson from Germany |  Editorial

The Guardian view on cheap train travel: a lesson from Germany | Editorial

The choice by one of many nation’s important train operators to scale back providers on the west coast mainline provides the newest proof of deep malaise within the rail trade. Citing employees shortages and “the present industrial local weather relations”, Avanti West Coast has put an emergency timetable in place, severely proscribing the variety of inter-city trains serving the north-west and Scotland. Aslef train drivers went on strike on Saturday. This week, the RMT union will resume its strike motion over job safety, pay and circumstances, because the transport secretary, Grant Shapps, seeks to impose cuts of £2bn a 12 months on a sector struggling to return to pre-Covid passenger numbers. It is a bleak image and, given the important function of public transport in decreasing carbon emissions, a miserable one. But a look at the remainder of Europe suggests it actually would not must be this manner.

In Germany, this has been the summer time of the train. In June, the SPD-led coalition authorities launched a closely backed and wildly standard €9 month-to-month public transport cross, designed to get folks out of vehicles and, on the similar time, ease the price of dwelling disaster. In June alone, 31 million folks purchased one. The most up-to-date information signifies a doubling of short-distance train journeys between 30km and 100km, in contrast with pre-Covid ranges. One in 5 passengers seem to have taken the chance to make use of public transport often for the primary time.

Similarly daring experiments are going down elsewhere, pushed by the long-term objective of decreasing carbon emissions and the short-term have to mitigate the impression of hovering gas prices. In Spain, one other socialist-led coalition administration is introducing free rail journey for commuters from September till the tip of the 12 months, and halving many different fares. Last 12 months, Austria launched the Klimaticket, an annual rail cross that prices about €21 a week. In 2020, Luxembourg made all journey on its trains and buses free. Estonia’s capital, Tallinn, has had free public transport since 2013.

Germany’s radical transfer prices an estimated €2.5bn in state subsides. Christian Lindner, the ruling coalition’s liberal finance minister, is insisting that funds will not be out there to proceed the €9 ticket past the tip of August, when the scheme is because of shut. There have at occasions been uncomfortable ranges of overcrowding, and it’s unsure patterns to what extent vacation season journey are related to the remainder of the 12 months. Initial audits additionally recommend that automobile utilization might have remained fixed. But in a nation well-known for its love affair with the automobile, political creativeness has opened up the chances of rail journey to extra folks and pointed the way in which to a cultural shift in tune with web zero targets. Mr Lindner’s inexperienced colleagues in authorities have known as for a successor scheme to be partly financed by ending tax breaks on firm vehicles. As a spokesperson for Deutsche Bahn, the nationwide rail firm, stated: “Holding on to those long-term riders is necessary for transport and local weather coverage.”

It could be good to assume that Mr Shapps – whose method to the RMT strikes has been to pit the general public in opposition to rail employees and replay the confrontational politics of the Nineteen Seventies – has observed that different nations are doing issues in another way. Sadly, evidently managed decline is the height of this authorities’s ambition for the railways. A visit to Berlin or Madrid would possibly assist the transport secretary see this strategic myopia and short-termism for what it’s.

Leave a Reply