Real Trademarks Used in Virtual Worlds

In April 2009 the world’s largest maker of stun weapons (“Company 1”) sued the proprietor of one of the vital fashionable “Virtual World” web pages (“Company 2”). Company 2’s site permits gamers, known as Residents, to work together with one another by avatars. Residents can discover, meet different residents, socialize, take part in particular person and group actions, and create and commerce digital property and providers with each other, or journey all through the world, which residents seek advice from because the grid. In its lawsuit, Company 1 claimed that Company 2 and different defendants broken Company 1’s repute and damage its gross sales by permitting digital weapons to be offered on-line below its model identify. Not solely did Company 1’s grievance alleged that Company 2 was infringing its emblems but additionally that it was claiming its repute by promoting the digital weaponry in the identical on-line shops that included pornographic content material.

The case was dismissed in May 2009, presumably as a result of the events settled their dispute. Nonetheless, the lawsuit ought to elevate issues about policing emblems in the digital world. The legislation imposes on trademark homeowners the obligation to police their emblems. Should your trademark be infringed and also you allow the infringement to proceed with out motion, you might be confronted with an argument that you’ve deserted your trademark. Traditionally, policing your emblems meant monitoring on-line and offline publications and different locations the place your trademark could also be infringed. Now that precise commerce is going on in digital communities akin to Virtual World, the scope of policing has widened. The purported inhabitants of this specific Virtual World is greater than 2 million though opinions differ. In phrases of, there are lots of people “enjoying the sport” and numerous firms from Reuters to IBM have arrange storefronts in Virtual World. It’s unclear what the annual GDP of Virtual World is — estimates vary from 64 to 200 million USD — however no matter it’s, it isn’t small.

With the commercialization of Virtual World by actual firms, concern in regards to the safety of mental property rights has grown. Copyright homeowners can defend their rights by the procedures of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA), which Virtual World states it’ll implement. The DMCA requires service suppliers upon discover from homeowners to take down and ban repeat infringers. It is to Virtual World’s profit to evolve with the DMCA or in any other case it too could also be topic to legal responsibility for its customers’ infringing actions.

Unfortunately, there isn’t a such protections for emblems. The DMCA doesn’t apply in this space, solely the provisions of the Lanham Act, which prohibits trademark infringement. Although Virtual World may have trademark rights by software of its phrases of Service, it particularly states that customers are chargeable for complying with mental property legislation however has no provision, like that of Facebook, for reporting violations. Apparently, nevertheless, there are violations aplenty. One commentator noticed:

“Ultimately, [Company 2] the creator of [Virtual World], depends on the vigilance of SL neighborhood residents to observe trademark and copyright abuses. Yet one boutique nonetheless sells a digital replica of the whole Ikea catalog. Virtual computer systems with the Apple emblem have been offered with out Apple’s permission. Residents stroll the streets of [Virtual World] carrying knockoff garments and are solicited by black-market distributors promoting whole traces of counterfeit items. [Company 2] I’ll not actively be looking for out offending materials, however most of the infringing acts are so rampant and blatant that ignoring these abuses virtually quantities to willful ignorance.” Chilling Effects.Org

Sounds just like the wild west so be vigilant.

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: